I make my living as a writer. Sure, game design and programming are part of it, but the main selling point of my games has always been the stories. Each game I write has over one hundred thousand words, enough for a decently sized novel. That means that many young, impressionable minds have spent hours and hours reading my writing, being infected by my questionable grammar and unwholesome penchant for. Sentence fragments.
Thus, when I take the side of the Visigoths who want to simplify the rules of our language, I get to have a actual (if small) influence on how my young readers write, simply by being a bad example. It is a grim responsibility, and, at times, I must take a stand. I must use my awesome Role Model power to Make a Difference. Therefore, I must make this proclamation.
I will never use the word "whom" again. It's stupid.
Turning My Ignorance Into a Sacred Principle
Actually, I still have no idea exactly when to write whom and whomever and whomungous. I must have had bronchitis the day they covered that in school. (The same day they explained how to tell what syllable is accented and how relativity works.) So, for the sixteen years I've spent writing my million words and counting, I've never used "whom" properly unless prompted by proofreading beta testers. The rest of the time, I used "who" and "whoever."
And you know something? Hasn't done a bit of harm. Hasn't harmed comprehensibility at all. Hasn't earned me a single complaint from a customer in sixteen years. And, believe me, I get complaints about everything.
Don't get me wrong. Grammar has its place, and its rules should be obeyed. First, however, it is fair to evaluate those rules and see if they carry their freight. Does the effort to have the rule justify itself with better communication?
In this case, no. Everything "whom" does can be done with "who." This inefficiency offends my soul.
Also, using "whom" makes one sound really, really affected and twitlike. Which is not usually my goal. (Only sometimes.)
So I'm done with it.
But I Believe In Compromise.
I have to admit that the word "whom" sounds pretty nice. It's an elegant, cultured sounding word, the sort of word that might be used by Jane Austen or an Ent. I can see that some might be saddened by its loss.
Therefore, I propose this compromise: You can use the word "whom" when it would be correct, under the old, dead rules. In addition, you can use "whom" whenever you would say "who," or whenever it would sound good, or at any other point.
For example, by this new, simple, elegant rule, the following sentences are considered to be correct:
"Whom just fell into the wheat thresher?"
"You must be the hobbits whom are from the Shire?"
"Whom whom whom hello there whom whom whom whom whom."
"You must be the hobbits whom are from the Shire?"
"Whom whom whom hello there whom whom whom whom whom."
Ahhhh. That Felt Kind Of Good.
I hope that all whom are reading this join me in my crusade against "whom." Being a Visigoth is really lots of fun. Give in.
And I wish upon all of you whom the same blessing I have been given: That, when you want to spend some time tearing down instead of building up, you also have access to at least a few young, impressionable minds. It's awesome. Whom.
0 comments:
Post a Comment